Environmentalists disdain 'voluntary' clean-up

Trading in clean-ups : Cap-and-trade system for carbon exchange may point way for U.S.
Corvallis Gazette-Times, March 31, 2008
By Les Blumenthal
McClatchy Newspapers

WASHINGTON — For nearly 50 years, Rocky Reach Dam on the Columbia River has been quietly producing enough low-cost electricity to power two cities the size of Seattle. Now the Washington state dam is on the front lines of the nation’s effort to control greenhouse-gas emissions and curb global warming.

The owner and operator of the dam, the Chelan County Public Utility District, figures that recent improvements it’s made mean that 700,000 metric tons of carbon dioxide won’t be pumped into the air. And it registered these “carbon offsets’’ on the Chicago Climate Exchange for sale to companies that need to reduce their emissions.

Other exchanges trade pork bellies, gold, Treasury bonds or wood pulp. But on the Chicago Climate Exchange, carbon offsets or credits are traded in what could be a precursor to a new national effort to slow climate change.

The players range from Fortune 500 companies to California’s Sacramento County, Florida’s Miami-Dade County and the Kentucky Corn Growers Association.

The system is called cap and trade. Early this summer, Congress is expected to consider legislation that would make it the cornerstone of U.S. efforts to reduce greenhouse gases.
Congress already is involved. Late last year, the House of Representatives purchased $98,000 worth of offsets on the Chicago Climate Exchange to offset greenhouse-gas emissions from its office buildings, including the U.S. Capitol. Among the offsets that the House purchased was one that involved farmers in North Dakota tilling in a way that preserved the carbon in the soil.

Other offsets for sale on the exchange include dairy methane reduction, reforestation, wind and biomass projects, not just in the United States but around the world, in such places as India, Germany, China and Brazil.

Rocky Reach Dam is the first hydroelectric project listed.

“It’s never been done before,’’ said Gregg Carrington, the director of external affairs for Chelan PUD. He said that of the 700,000 metric tons of carbon offsets the utility had for sale, about 160,000 had been sold.

The idea is simple, but a cap-and-trade system could be enormously complicated to implement.
In a nutshell, federal law would cap greenhouse gas emissions at a certain level, and the cap would be reduced over the years. Manufacturers, utilities, state and local governments and others have to reduce their emissions if they exceed certain levels, either by installing equipment to lower the emissions or buying offsets or credits from other entities. If they’re below their caps, they have offsets or credits to sell.

A similar program helped significantly reduce sulfur dioxide emissions in the 1990s, which were causing acid rain.

Formed in 2003, the Chicago Climate Exchange, known as CCX, doesn’t have a trading floor with traders yelling orders in a frenzy of bidding. Everything is handled electronically.

The exchange has nearly 400 members, including large industrial companies, utilities, local and state governments, universities and nonprofit organizations.

Some, such as the Chelan PUD, just offer carbon offsets for sale. Others undergo thorough audits of their emissions and then sign an agreement to start reducing them. The members have reduced their emissions, on average, by 12 percent below their commitments, representing more than 180 million metric tons of greenhouse gas emissions. Credits, or offsets, are selling at about $5.50 per metric ton, though the price fluctuates daily.

Similar exchanges have been established in Europe, where a mandatory cap-and-trade system is already in place, and in Canada.

“Through CCX and its affiliated exchanges, the financial, capital and regulatory structures needed for an internationally linked carbon-trading system are well-advanced," CCX chief executive Richard Sandor told the Senate Foreign Relations Committee late last year. “The environmental and economic benefits being generated are of national and global significance."
If Congress does establish a national, mandatory cap-and-trade system, Sandor expects CCX to play a leading role in implementing it, he said in an e-mail. “We will operationalize whatever the government mandates, and as the first mover we expect to dominate the market," he said.

Some environmental groups urged municipal governments, states and others not to get involved with CCX because it was voluntary, there were too many loopholes and it would preclude them from becoming involved in other programs to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. [Emphasis added]

Henry Henderson of the Natural Resources Defense Council said his environmental organization supported a national cap-and-trade system. “We won’t get to where we need to with a voluntary program like CCX," he said. [Emphasis added]

On Capitol Hill, interest is growing in a cap-and-trade system for greenhouse gas emissions, though the details are far from being resolved. There’s also a certain cautiousness among lawmakers, even among those who support the system.

“While tackling climate change is the most urgent and important environmental challenge facing our generation, any greenhouse-gas reduction strategy has to be efficient, effective and put consumers first,’’ said Sen. Maria Cantwell, D-Wash.

For more information on the Chicago Climate Exchange: http://www.chicagoclimatex.com/

HOW ONE CAP-AND-TRADE PROGRAM WORKED: In the 1980s, acid rain resulting mostly from sulfur dioxide emissions from coal-fired power plants was devastating forests, lakes, streams and wildlife in the Northeast and elsewhere across the country. As part of the 1990 Clean Air Act, Congress adopted a cap-and-trade system for sulfur dioxide emissions that could become a model for greenhouse gas emissions.

Under the system, sulfur dioxide emissions must be reduced by 50 percent from 1980 levels by 2010. Utilities and other companies either could install pollution-abatement equipment or purchase credits from companies that were below their emissions caps.

So far, sulfur dioxide emissions have dropped 40 percent from earlier levels. The government’s new goal is to reduce emissions to 20 percent of 1990 levels by 2015.

There are signs that the forests, lakes and rivers have started to recover.

Some members of the Chicago Climate Exchange include: Ford Motor Co., DuPont, Bank of America Corp., Sony Electronics Inc., Intel Corp., IBM, Safeway Inc., International Paper, Cargill Inc., Sacramento County, Calif., King County, Wash., Miami-Dade County, Fla., University of Idaho, The state of Illinois, The state of New Mexico, The city of Portland, Ore., The city of Chicago, The city of Berkeley, Calif., San Joaquin Regional Rail Commission (Calif.), Kentucky Corn Growers Association.

Complete list of members: http://www.chicagoclimatex.com/content.jsf?id=64